Stalin s genocides is compellingly written, nuanced and powerfully argued. Stalins genocides, many millions of innocent people died under stalins rule. During a window of opportunity from 1945 to 1948, leaders across the political spectrum, including juho kusti paasikivi of finland, wladyslaw gomulka of poland, and karl renner of austria, pushed back against outside pressures. N35 2010 first floor stacks abstract from the book cover between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a million of his own citizens executed.
This short book really an extended essayis intended to argue that stalins mass killings of the 1930s should be classified as genocide. The chilling story of stalin s crimes against humanity. But stalin was more open to a settlement on the continent than is assumed. He looks at the most consequential and harrowing episodes of stalins. The cold war division of europe was not inevitablethe acclaimed author of stalins genocides shows how postwar europeans fought to determine their own destinies was the division of europe after world war ii inevitable.
In this powerful reassessment of the postwar order in europe, norman naimark suggests that joseph stalin was far more open to a settlement on the continent than we have. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in. For naimark, labeling stalins mass killing genocide entails a rigorous exegesis of the concept itself its history, legal complexities, boundaries, and universe. We need a much broader definition of genocide, one that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. Stalin s genocides is a magisterial and admirably lucid analysis of the stalinist terrors that is both totally accessible and finely nuanced in its scholarship naimark s superb work assigns the criminality to stalins own bizarre personality as well as the repressive soviet system. Perspectives on norman naimarks stalins genocides journal. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass kill. Naimark 2011, trade paperback at the best online prices at ebay. Many historians have argued that genocide is a form of mass killing that began only in the 20th century with the advent of the modernist state, extreme nationalist ideologies, mass media and.
Millions more fell victim to forced labor, deportation, famine, bloody massacres, and detention and interrogation by stalins henchmen. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The cold war division of europe was not inevitable. Stalin s genocides human rights and crimes against humanity kindle edition by naimark, norman m download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Yet naimark reveals a surprisingly flexible stalin, who initially had no intention of dividing europe. As norman naimark points out in his thoughtprovoking stalin s genocides princeton up, 2010, historians and others have been peculiarly conflicted about this issue. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings. Blood and soil is an important and courageous attempt to write a world history of genocide from sparta to darfur. But the russian government and some western writers continue to argue that these murders were not genocidal, and that stalin therefore. The destruction of the jewish community in jedwabne, poland, this is a small book that places a large exclamation point on the most incriminatingly tragic dimension of soviet history. Naimark is author of the critically acclaimed volumes the russians in germany.
She calls naimark s argument authoritative, clear, and hard to dispute. Jul 19, 2010 stalins genocides is the chilling story of these crimes. He concludes the book with a comparison of stalin to the twentieth centurys most famous genocidaire, adolf hitler. Naimark, however, argues stalin s crimes should be considered genocide on three grounds. Dec 25, 2011 stalin s genocides is a magisterial and admirably lucid analysis of the stalinist terrors that is both totally accessible and finely nuanced in its scholarship. First, the previous united nations definition of genocide has recently been expanded to include murder on a social and political basis. Stalins genocides norman m naimark haftad 9780691152387. Naimark s superb work assigns the criminality to stalin s own bizarre personality as well as the repressive soviet system. Few any longer deny that stalins regime slaughtered millions of innocent people. Buy a cheap copy of stalin s genocides book by norman m. Coddling, fraternization, and total war in camp crossville. Stalin, perpetrator of the multiple examples behind the book. Most of the commentators praise the book highly but raise some questions about. He argues that the soviet elimination of a social classes e.
Naimark is the robert and florence mcdonnell professor of east european studies at stanford university. A history of the soviet zone of occupation, 19451949. Pdf on jun 1, 2012, lavinia stan published stalin s genocides. Third, during the ukrainian famine in 19321933, victims were deliberately starved by the soviet state. The history of the soviet zone of occupation, 19451949 harvard, 1995, fires of hatred. The book does a good job of describing and cataloging some of the crimes of stalin. This lecture summarizes the argument of a forthcoming book suhrkamp, princeton university press that stalin s crimes of the 1930s should be considered genocide. Europe between hitler and stalin as well as stalins genocides. Was the division of europe after world war ii inevitable. Millions more fell victim to forced labor, deportation, famine, bloody massacres, and detention and interrogation by stalin s henchmen.
Nov 01, 2010 for naimark, labeling stalin s mass killing genocide entails a rigorous exegesis of the concept itself its history, legal complexities, boundaries, and universe. Nov 06, 20 norman naimark argues that these crimes should be considered genocide and that joseph stalin should therefore be labeled a genocidaire. Stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity kindle edition by naimark, norman m download it once and read it on your kindle device. Dec 25, 2011 buy stalin s genocides human rights and crimes against humanity reprint by naimark, norman m. Naimark has 23 books on goodreads with 1939 ratings. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read stalin s genocides. This is a small book that places a large exclamation point on the most incriminatingly tragic dimension of soviet history. Dec 25, 2011 stalins genocides is the chilling story of these crimes. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in the 1930s were indeed acts of genocide and that the soviet dictator himself. Ethnic cleansing in 20th century europe harvard, 2001, and stalin s genocides princeton, 2010. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in the 1930s were indeed acts of genocide and that the soviet dictator himself was behind them.
This forum includes commentaries by seven expertsjoshua rubenstein, paul hollander, andrea graziosi, roman szporluk, jeffrey hardy, michael ellman, and jeffrey rossmanon norman naimark s stalin s genocides, published by princeton university press in 2010. Sep 23, 2010 naimark, author of the controversial new book stalin s genocides, argues that we need a much broader definition of genocide, one that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. Jan 26, 2012 stalin s genocides is a magisterial and admirably lucid analysis of the stalinist terrors that is both totally accessible and finely nuanced in its scholarship naimark s superb work assigns the criminality to stalin s own bizarre personality as well as the repressive soviet system. He tells us how genocide happens, who denies it, where it could return, and the best books to read about it. Naimark lucidly shows that genocide both changes over time, depending on the character of major historical periods, and remains the same in many of its. In this powerful reassessment of the postwar order in europe. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading stalin s genocides human rights and crimes against humanity.
Most of the commentators praise the book highly but raise some questions about specific points, such as the use of the term. Stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity. Naimark, 2010, princeton university press edition, in english. The best books on genocide five books expert recommendations. Stalins genocides, written by norman m naimark princeton. Nov 23, 2010 in his excellent recent book stalins genocides, stanford historian norman naimark argues that joseph stalin committed genocide and not merely mass murder. Demonstrators in prague holding pictures of vaclav havel, 11 december 1989, pavel khol ctk. Stalin s genocides, written by norman m naimark princeton university press, 2010 logue library call number. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading stalin s genocides human.
Stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity 8. They were shot, starved or died during imprisonment or exile. Genocide occurs in every time period and on every continent. Human rights and crimes against humanity ser stalins. In his new book, historian norman naimark argues that the definition of genocide should include nations. Sep 23, 2010 naimark, author of the controversial new book stalins genocides, argues that we need a much broader definition of genocide, one that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. Stalins genocides is the chilling story of these crimes. This argument is made more difficult by the fact that there was no single act of genocide in the soviet case, but rather a series of interrelated attacks on class enemies and enemies of. It can seem as though the cold war division of europe was inevitable. Naimark s work brings emphasize of the state of flux the region was in from reconstruction, political standpoints, and. Naimark, author of the new book stalins genocides princeton university press, 2010, argues that the world needs a much broader definition of genocide that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. Stalins genocides by norman naimark 2011 not even past. He argues that stalin committed the crime of genocide based on his establishment policies, historical facts and events, and comparing the nazis regime to stalins. Naimark s work brings emphasize of the state of flux the region was in from reconstruction, political standpoints, and other issues brought from the ending of the war.
What is not well established is what to call stalin s crimes. Stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity 8 naimark, norman m. He presents four major arguments to support this claim. In this gripping book, naimark explains how stalin became a pitiless mass killer. Dec 21, 2019 in naimarks account, stalin was no dogmatic tyrant determined to foist communist dictatorships on hapless and exhausted countries but rather a hyperrealist, who was ready to endorse governing. Norman naimark is the robert and florence mcdonnell professor of east. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under. Please introduce ben kiernans book for us, and the genocides it covers. Genocide isnt the preserve of fanatics and racist thugs its part of human nature, says stanford historian norman naimark. Perhaps the most interesting aspect of the book is naimarks discussion of the term genocide, which was coined by the polishjewish legal scholar raphael lemkin in 1944. In this powerful reassessment of the postwar order, norman naimark returns to the four years after wwii to illuminate european leaders efforts to secure national sovereignty amid dominating powers. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in the 1930s were indeed acts of genocide and that the.
Naimark starts his book by declaring, stalins mass killings of the 1930s should be classified as genocide. Naimark s contention, in his controversial new book stalins genocides. Ethnic cleansing in twentiethcentury europe and the russians in germany. Stalin, perpetrator of the multiple examples behind the books plural title. Between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a million of his own citizens executed. New books network norman naimark, stalins genocides. Simon sebag montefiore, author of young stalin and stalin. Norman naimark is the robert and florence mcdonnell professor of east european studies. In total, stalin is responsible for the murder of roughly 10 million soviet citizens. Stalin s genocides is the chilling story of these crimes. Naimark s book, stalin and the fate of europe 2019, focuses on seven different case studies within the postwar years of 19441949 within the region of europe. September 25, 2016 norman naimark s extended essay turned book, stalins genocides, questions what makes mass murder a genocide.
487 681 429 1437 1170 515 1063 140 845 698 1379 135 1105 950 366 51 574 1085 794 1134